‘Shadowhunters’ TV REVIEW

Cassandra Clare’s ‘The Mortal Instruments’ have been some of my favourite books for many years. An immensely popular YA fiction series that creates rich characters, wonderful story arcs and twisted relationships that would make a wonderful soap drama in the world of supernatural. So when they announced they were making a film version a few years ago, I was thrilled. After seeing it, a little less so. Don’t get me wrong, it was good but- it wasn’t exactly gripping. The casting seemed off, too many things were changed from the original text and I just felt some of the magic got lost on the crossover from page to screen. 

But, thank goodness, we as a fandom were given a second chance in the form of a television show. A chance for the media Gods to redeem themselves, if you like. But the whole world was watching, and every eye was on McG and Ed Decter, the shows producers, to do a better job that had been done before. Every member of the fandom had an opinion on who to be cast in the beloved teen roles of Jace and Clary, not to mention Alec, Izzy, Simon and Magnus- and all opinions were different. It seemed an impossible task to get right, but somehow, they managed it. Well, almost managed it. A couple of casting choices seemed a little dubious to me, but we will get to that later. 

Next came the story-line- what parts of the novel were the writers going to keep, and what was going to be added? Would they go completely off book to keep the plot alive and interesting- after all, as much as we love the books, knowing everything that is going to happen before it actually does was bound to get tedious for fans of the novels. The writers had a hard task of sticking to the plot as well as inventing new twists and turns to keep us as viewers captivated. There’s a very thin line between staying true to the original story and throwing it away for artistic license- and with fans as passionate as the ones of ‘The Mortal Instruments’, it’s not a line you would want to cross.

Especially with regards to the relationships that are present in the novel. With characters as rich and dimensional as the ones Clare had created on the page, there comes a lot of drama, romance and emotions. the fans were desperate for that to come across on the screen as well as it does in the books. The witty banter between Jace and Clary is crucial to their relationship, it’s what makes it stand out and so much fun to read- the shameless flirting from Magnus and the awkward bashfulness from Alec is so important for their journey and had to be included, otherwise it would simply fall flat- both from the writers and the actors. These are characters we know so intimately, after six books plus extras written all about them, it’s easy enough to say you know them as well as your own family. Everyone’s a critic when it comes to something you’re passionate about. 

I personally am much happier with the casting choices, overall, for the TV series than I was for the film. Yes, there are a couple of actors I would have loved to have bought over from film to TV land, such as Jared Harris in the role of Hodge who, to me, was just perfection. I very much enjoy Jon Corr as an actor, but when a character is described a certain way in a novel I prefer to see that same description on the screen as well. 

The stand out roles for me, without a doubt, were Alec and Magnus, played by Matthew Daddario and Harry Shum Jr. respectively. And not just because I am such a fan of their characters together, but because they really embodied the main personality traits their characters’ possess. Shum Jr. manages to use his dancing background to give Magnus the flair and ‘sparkle’ that he deserves, playing the magical warlock with a sharp tongue and a ‘c’est le vie’ attitude about most things with a credit to his skills. Whilst Daddario portrays a stoic and strict version of Alec that compliments his other half Magnus. He plays the leader with great authority, but shows the vulnerable side of Alec that stems from his struggles regarding sexuality and feelings in a way that makes you find him endearing and a joy to watch. 

Other members of the cast such as  Emeraude Toubia and Alberto Rosende, who bring Izzy and Simon to life on screen, really did their characters justice in their portrayals. The changes made to the character of Luke Garroway, played by Isaiah Mustafa, turning him from a bookkeeper to a detective really worked favorably for the plot-line and the story arc of the entire season. The older generation of characters, the parental roles, really hold their own- they have more prominent roles than in the movie which is also something I enjoyed- to see the family aspect of the show and the novels really come to life. 

And now we move onto the two leads of the show, Jace and Clary portrayed by Dominic Sherwood and Katherine McNamara. Whilst I appreciate there can be pressure and responsibility when playing the lead in a show, something about the performances felt…flat. McNamara’s portrayal seemed forced, her facial expressions too dramatic and the words just not seeming quite natural. Physically she matches Clary from the book perfectly, but her over innocence and dramatic outbursts become tiresome fairly quickly in the series. Her chemistry with Dominic Sherwood cannot be faulted however, and when the two share the screen it really is hard to look away. They play off each other with ease- the flirtatious game Jace and Clary are known for in the first novel very clear on screen. Sherwood’s portrayal of Jace is very well done- he nails the sarcasm to a tee and he’s got the looks as well, but I don’t know if its simply because I have built a certain, very clear image of Jace in my head over the years that makes me a little bias to anyone playing him, but something seems off. I don’t know if its because Sherwood’s Jace is a lot angrier and hot tempered than I remember Jace being in the novels- he was always the ‘scary calm’ type rather than shouting his feelings. Or maybe it’s just the script itself I struggled with. 

The script had it’s ups and down for me. The plot I enjoyed immensely, because it was a nice mixture of the original text and new ideas, but the dialogue seemed overkill. There was such an information dump and obvious lines that could have been expressed with emotion or movement rather than words. It felt jarring at times, like the actors were trying to catch the audience up with all the information they needed to know so that the next scene made scene. It was a little disconcerting, and broke up the dialogue and the scene quite a bit. Above all else, it felt a little insulting to the audience, as if we needed to be spoon fed information to understand the show. I did, however, like how each character had their own story line and own issues to deal with, all whilst being tied together by the main story arc- defeating the villain Valentine, played by Alan Van Sprang. 

The costumes and styles definitely need a mention as well- what the characters wear is a huge part in the novels, ‘wearing black better than the widows of our enemies’ runs a strong theme throughout all of Clare’s shadowhunter novels, and the costume designers did not disappoint. Leather as far as the eye could see, weapons galore and more black material than you could shake a stick at- I loved it. The characters totally looked the part, and the costumes are something I cannot fault. And the wedding dress…I’ll say no more. 

And moving swiftly from the costumes to a new but not entirely unrelated topic, the settings- in particular the Shadowhunter Institute where the characters live and work- are all incredible as well. The set designers have outdone themselves, building the apartment where Clary and her mother live, the institute itself, and various other settings that help support the story line. 

The last thing I wanted to address was the changes to the original story whilst it was being adapted. There are many people out there who want the story to remain the same, to just see the original text up on the screen with no changes, and I understand that. When you love something, you don’t want to see it changed- perhaps for worse. It’s a risk the writers, and the fans, have to take when a project like this is green-lit. But personally, I liked the changes. The main events stay the same but there are many twists and turns that I really enjoyed throughout the season- it made it seem fresh and new, and gave the story another dimension. 

And, luckily for us as a fandom, the show has been picked up for a season 2, coming early 2017. I, for one, cannot wait to see where the story is going to go. 

6.5/10